Starz Arena Logo

Top 10 Greatest Lacrosse Players 2024 Guide

Greatest Lacrosse Players Of All Time

Greatest Lacrosse Players, often called “the fastest game on two feet,” have a history spanning centuries. From its origins as a Native American tradition to its modern-day status as one of the fastest-growing sports in the United States, lacrosse has produced some genuinely remarkable athletes. This article will delve into the lives and legacies of some of the greatest lacrosse players to ever grace the field.

10. Jason Coffman – Popular Lacrosse Player

Jason Coffman Greatest Lacrosse Players

He was a fantastic player, well-known for his lightning-fast play and acute sense of the net. With 451 points, he concluded his career at Salisbury as the NCAA’s all-time top scorer. That record doesn’t seem to be breaking anytime soon, even as the shot clock era progresses.

In addition to his numerous other achievements, Coffman of Salisbury was a member of the first two national title-winning teams. As an attacker, he was selected twice for Player of the Year (1994, 1995) and four times for the first team of the All-American team (1993, 1994, 1995, and 1996).

In addition to having 249 career goals, 202 lifetime assists, and 126 points in a single season, Coffman is among the top five NCAA players in terms of career points. Because of his incredible career in lacrosse, Coffman is regarded as one of the sport’s all-time greats.

Coffman had one of the best and most underappreciated careers in game history. He has never been given the respect or recognition he so well deserves, and his name ought to be in the National Lacrosse Hall of Fame alongside the other greats of the game.

9. Jim Thorpe – Lacrosse Star

Jim Thorpe

Jim Thorpe was the most outstanding athlete of the 20th century after winning the pentathlon and decathlon in 1912. For technical concerns, however, his gold medals were withdrawn. Later on, someone felt that it was unfair to him.

It’s debatable whether he’s one of the best. His life’s work and successes bear witness to themselves. Thorpe is one of the few athletes who participated in several sports in their prime.

King Gustav V named Thorpe the “world’s greatest athlete” because of his exceptional athletic ability. Thorpe was born in Oklahoma on May 28, 1887, and played professional baseball and football.

After retirement, he turned acting into a career. He could tell right away that he was athletically gifted.
While in Carlisle, he also set several records. Furthermore, his victories over the Army, Pittsburgh, Harvard, Penn, Syracuse, and Nebraska made him one of the nation’s best lacrosse players.

8. Oren Lyons – Iconic Lacrosse Player

Oren Lyons

Oren R. Lyons Jr., the Wolf Clan Faith Keeper, was born in Seneca, New York 1930. As a member of the Six Nations, the Seneca tribe is part of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy. Throughout his career, he has served in leadership capacities on the UN Human Rights Commission and the Indigenous Peoples Working Group of the Commission.

Lyons is regarded as one of the best lacrosse players and has had an outstanding athletic career. He consistently astounded sports enthusiasts with exceptional performances and accomplishments.

After college, the former Syracuse University lacrosse standout started speaking out more for Indigenous peoples. He joined the University at Buffalo faculty and was appointed a professor of American Studies.

Lyons attended Syracuse University on an athletic scholarship, excelled academically and athletically, and was awarded the Orange Key.

7. John Grant Sr. – Lax Expert

John Grant Senior

John Christopher Grant Jr. was born in Toronto, Ontario, on November 7, 1974, and is a former player for the Ontario Lacrosse Association, the National Lacrosse League, and Major League Lacrosse. Grant Jr. was appointed offensive coordinator for the men’s lacrosse team at Johns Hopkins in 2020.

Before he became a celebrity, John Grant Sr. played lacrosse with the Ontario Lacrosse Association and the first Philadelphia Wings. The oldest, Grant Jr., sometimes known as Junior, graduated from the University of Delaware with a degree in physical education. In addition, he was one of this sport’s most significant athletes.

Grant first participated in the Ontario Lacrosse Association’s Junior A Lacrosse League as a junior lacrosse player with the Peterborough Lakers. Among the high points of his career have been his All-American selections in 1993, 1994, and 1995. With the Peterborough Lakers of the Major Series Lacrosse (MSL), he was the 1995 winner of the Top Rookie of the Year award. In 2000, he received the MSL Most Valuable Player award.

Fans hold Grant in high regard as one of the greatest lacrosse players ever. In addition, Grant was an All-Star for the Coquitlam Adanacs in the Western Lacrosse Association from 2002 to 2003.

6. Jimmy Lewis – Greatest Living Lacrosse Player

Jimmy Lewis

All-American lacrosse: Between 1964 and 1966, James C. Lewis played for the Navy, helping his team win three national crowns and a perfect season each time. The Wingate Memorial Trophy structure helped the Navy win its national championships throughout these years, as a committee chose the winners. 1966, Lewis was regarded as the “greatest living lacrosse player,” according to The Baltimore Sun.

Lewis is fifth all-time in lacrosse, scoring points during his tenure at the Navy. Lewis was a team member during his three years in college, winning the Jack Turnbull Award in 1964, 1965, and 1966. He is regarded as the greatest lacrosse player of all time and was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1981 while playing for the Navy.

Lewis’s stellar career has made them one of the best lacrosse players. Lewis guided the Navy to a 12 and 0 record while defeating Army 18-7, giving the Midshipmen their fourth consecutive undefeated national championship. The Navy has now won 22 straight games.

Lewis guided the Navy to three consecutive National Championships during the period when USILA voted for the best teams. The Navy won eight successive national titles or shared eight of them in the years that separated 1960 and 1968. This is thought to be the best run of lacrosse in Navy history.

Read More: Top 10 Greatest Poker Players

5. Dave Pietramala – Pro Lacrosse Coach

Dave Pietramala

Dave Pietramala, the former men’s lacrosse team head coach at Johns Hopkins University, was born in 1967. One of the best defensemen in lacrosse history, the inductee of the U.S. Lacrosse Hall of Fame is widely recognized. He has won player and coach of the year awards as a men’s lacrosse player and coach.

John attended St. Mary’s High School and was born and raised in Hicksville, New York. After receiving recommendations from George Pietramala, Pietramala decided to play lacrosse for the dominant Johns Hopkins University. Pietramala was a member of the Hopkins squad that won the 1987 National Championship. He received the Schmeisser Award in 1988 and 1989 for being the best defenseman in the country.

In addition, he received the 1989 Enners Award, which recognized him as the nation’s finest Player. He also won three first-team all-American titles at Hopkins. The International Lacrosse Federation recognized him with MVP (Best and Fairest Player) honors and All-World choices in 1990 and 1994.

Pietramala was selected for the Johns Hopkins All-Time Team, Lacrosse Magazine’s All-Century Team, and the 1995 NCAA Silver Anniversary Team. After receiving further honors, he has become one of the all-time best lacrosse players. He was admitted to the National Lacrosse Hall of Fame in 2004.

4. Michael Powell – Professional Lacrosse Star

Michael Powell Greatest Lacrosse Players

Michael Powell, born October 29, 1982, was a four-time Syracuse University honorable mention All-American who played for the Boston Cannons and Baltimore Bay Hawks.

In addition, he participated for the US team in the World Lacrosse Championships in 2002 and 2006, earning All-World honors both times. Powell is the only Player to have earned the Jack Turnbull Award six times in a row and was the finest attackman in Division I lacrosse. He was also the recipient of the Tewaaraton Trophy, lacrosse’s version of the Heisman Trophy, throughout his career.

Powell is one of just two male players to have won the Tewaraton Trophies twice. He owns the school record for career points and was one of Syracuse’s first two national champions, making him one of the all-time great lacrosse players.

3. Paul Rabil – Highest-paid Lacrosse Player

paul rabil

He co-founded the Premier Lacrosse League’s Cannons Lacrosse Club, where he plays professionally under the name Paul Rabil. His prior Major League Lacrosse teams were the New York Lizards and the Boston Cannons.

Rabil was chosen first overall by the Boston Cannons in the 2008 Major League Lacrosse Collegiate Draft. He also participated in that year’s MLL All-Star Game.

Rabil took home the MLL MVP and Offensive Player Awards for the 2009 campaign. In 2010, Rabil, a first-team all-pro, was selected to the all-star squad for the third consecutive year. Aside from that, Rabil was named the 2011 Offensive Player of the Year and MVP for the second time.

Furthermore, in 2011, he became the first Player to win the MLL Fastest Shot and the MLL Bud Light Skills Competition. He is regarded as one of the world’s top lacrosse players.

2. Brodie Merrill – Best Lacrosse Player 

brodie merrill

Canadian lacrosse player Brodie Merrill was born November 5, 1981, in Orangeville, Ontario. He now plays for the Premier Lacrosse League’s Cannons and the National Lacrosse League’s San Diego Seals.

As a member of the Baltimore Bayhawks, Merrill was the 2005 MLL Rookie of the Year winner. He spent 2006 and 2007 as a player with the Rochester Rattlers. Merrill has been named the Major League Lacrosse Defensive Player of the Year four times throughout his career.

In the Toronto Nationals’ debut season, he won the Defensive Player of the Year title four times in a row after helping the team win its first MLL Championship. Merrill is the current owner of the all-time groundball record.

He competed for Canada in the 2006 World Lacrosse Championships held in London, Ontario. He was also named All-World after emerging victorious in a fantastic tournament as Best Defender.

1. Gary Gait – Top Lacrosse Ninja

Gary Gait

Gary Charles Gait, a former professional lacrosse player, was born on April 5, 1967. He is currently the head coach of Syracuse University’s men’s lacrosse team. On January 24, 2017, he was appointed as the United Women’s Lacrosse League’s Interim Commissioner.

During his professional career, he represented Canada internationally and played in the outdoor Major League Lacrosse and the indoor National Lacrosse League. The United States Lacrosse National Hall of Fame and the National Lacrosse League have honored several of Gait’s achievements. Because of his outstanding career and play, Gait is among the all-time best lacrosse players.

He won an NCAA championship in 1988 and 1990 and was a four-time All-American for the Syracuse Orange men’s lacrosse team. At Georgetown, he was honored with two Lieutenant Raymond Enners Awards for the best collegiate lacrosse players. Until 2008, Syracuse and Gait held NCAA records for their individual and career goals.

Gait was named the league MVP five times in a row, from 1995 to 1999, and took home All-Pro titles each time. During his indoor career, Gait topped the league in goals and points seven times, setting a record with 1,091 points.


In conclusion, the greatest lacrosse players have left an indelible mark on the sport and shaped its history and future. From pioneers like Jim Brown and Gary Gait to modern-day legends like John Grant Jr. and Megan Taylor, these athletes have pushed the boundaries of what is possible on the lacrosse field. Their contributions, both on and off the field, serve as a testament to lacrosse’s enduring power and appeal as a sport.

Leave a Comment